The Vaunted “Garage” Creation Myth: Why it Damages the Federal Science Enterprise

In a musty garage at 367 Addison Ave., Palo Alto, Calif., in 1938, two chaps — William Hewlett and David Packard — built an audio oscillator, the HP200A.  Later, they sold eight of them to Walt Disney Studios to certify the sound systems in theaters that would feature the first major film released in stereophonic sound, “Fantasia.”  The results: The birth of Silicon Valley and the creation of an enduring myth about innovation.

Soon, others piled on.  Apple.  Cisco.  Intel.  Bill Gates.  Steve Jobs.  They “represent” millionaire inventors and entrepreneurs who made their fortunes not by getting their hands dirty with government assistance, but by rolling up their sleeves, sequestering themselves in their mythic garages, and spinning brilliant products that would change the modern world.

But here’s the problem:  none of it is really true.

As Argonne National Laboratory director Eric Isaacs remarked in Slate.com in May, “As Americans, we tend to embrace the notion that a brilliant inventor doesn’t need much more than a garage, a sturdy workbench, and a dream…our inventor-heroes have been popularly viewed as single-combat warriors working feverishly in a basement or some other threadbare den of solitude.”

The reality, of course, is that even Messrs. Hewlett and Packard benefited from critical assistance via the federal science enterprise in garnering their vast technological fortune.  “It’s certainly true that Hewlett and Packard began building their first commercial audio oscillators inside that historic garage. But the prototype of those oscillators was built in the laboratory of Stanford University electrical engineering professor Frederick Terman.  And Packard later wrote that many of those early devices were built using technical equipment at an engineering lab owned by a friend, an engineer and entrepreneur named Charles Litton. So while that Palo Alto garage may be a legendary landmark for the IT industry, Hewlett-Packard would not have been possible without its founders’ access to state-of-the-art engineering labs.”

But what’s the harm of a little mythology to inspire people to shoot for the stars?

Business professors Pino Audia and Christopher Rider wrote that the so-called “garage belief”  is “a symbol that conjures up some common images of entrepreneurship, including the inspirational generation of innovative ideas, old-fashioned hard work and American ingenuity, bootstrapping resources to chase a dream, a rejection of the status quo and the freedom of working for oneself.”

Not only is the “garage belief” inaccurate, but it does a colossal disservice to the critical role the federal government plays in launching new ideas, technologies and  innovations that help our economy thrive.

Dr. Isaacs writes, “These romanticized versions of technological history aren’t just inaccurate. They threaten to undermine public support for the scientific infrastructure that is necessary to fuel American innovation and assure global economic competitiveness in the decades to come.”  That scientific infrastructure so critical to the evolution of technological history, is now principally fueled by federally funded scientific research.  There is no longer a Xerox PARC or a Bell Labs.  Corporate research budgets have shrunk dramatically, and corporations cannot afford to invest in innovations that may take 10 to 15 years to reach fruition, if ever.  The federal scientific research enterprise is, therefore, critical as the incubator of new ideas, flights of scientific fancy, and the “seed corn” of the next big thing.

And that brings us back to the garage myth.

At a time when federally funded science is being threatened with the axe of the sequester, when many view science as just another special interest, or worse, an element of “big government” to be starved and excised, the fiction perpetuated by the mythical “garage” compounds the damage.

It gives painfully short shrift to the critical role the federal government plays in helping our nation’s scientists give birth to discoveries that could change our lives.  What’s worse:  It could result in our country becoming a technological also-ran in the increasingly competitive global economy.

2 Comments

  1. Posted February 5, 2013 at 5:26 PM | Permalink | Reply

    There are loads of young electricians job seeking these days, the number
    of applications I am receiving lately is overwhelming. If you are looking at becoming an electrical engineer these
    days then you should decide upon a specialist area of
    interest, by doing this you will find there’s much less job competition and also you typically get a larger salary!

  2. Dr. Victor Pinks II
    Posted December 6, 2012 at 1:43 PM | Permalink | Reply

    Perhaps “the garage” represents an environment of research thinking more akin to a “think tank”? In this day and age its difficult to see how ‘high impact’ innovation can occur without federal support because commercial industry is so risk averse. This is not good for national security.

    As history shows, the national labs are the only real friends of entrepreneurs that truly understand the garage spirit. The truth must be told and successful partnerships advertised to dispell the harmful myths.

    I believe that increased discretionary spending powers of facilities like ANL can be mutually beneficial for the lab and the entrepreneur. This way the labs can share the success of the entrepreneur by incubating innovation at even ealier stages that require less expenditure.

    Of course, the science must stand on its own merit and the entrepreneurs’ IP must be respected. But such an early relationship can be mutually beneficial (re: royalties and ownership) if national labs are willing to play a part in the commercialization process (if they choose to do so).

    If no more than these few reasons, I believe that we need to support garage thinkers as citizen scientists and to greatly increase discretionary spending at national labs to assist them. This is good for national security.

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38 other followers

%d bloggers like this: